Make your own free website on Tripod.com

December 17 PM

 

Home
Player Backgrounds
Casualties
Luck
Post Game Analysis
December 16 AM
December 16 PM
December 17AM
December 17 PM
December 18 AM
December 18 PM
December 19 AM
December 19 PM
December 20 AM
December 20 PM
December 21 AM
December 21 PM
December 22 AM
December 22 PM
December 23 AM
December 23 PM
December 24 AM
December 24 PM
December 25 AM
December 25 PM
December 26 AM

"A Determined Defense"

German 17 PM

Ger17PMAdvance.jpg (211777 bytes)Randy's defense certainly put the 'bitter' into these woods.  

I couldn't find any opportunities to exploit and thus had to resort to head-on assaults.  For the most part, I try to achieve 4-1(-2) odds in order to have a 50% chance of eliminating a unit.  Both of Randy's air units were committed to interdiction which allowed me to ensure that my attack with the 1SS Panzer would not face a possible ENG result.  Skorzeny goes into Malmedy and I suspect that this will force the US to defend carefully in that area.  I am way behind schedule in the South and need to play catchup quickly.  (During the exploitation phase, I bring Brandenberger back into the heart of the 7th Army area; he won't be able to add much to 5th Panzer Army's efforts.)  5th and 6th Panzer Army's seem to be making ground but the US defense is a little too 'thick' for my liking  Any time I see the US being able to defend with stacks outside of VP hexes, I think to myself that something isn't going right.  =)

The combat results were unkind; in fact, the worst results so far as measured purely by LQ.  I feel fortunate to have eliminated two Allied steps, otherwise the turn was a relative bust.  Next turn should be interesting as I try to pry open the roads to the Meuse before the US flood of reinforcements make their presence felt.

--  Tom

Allied 17 PM  

US17PMMove.jpg (201336 bytes)Tom's disappointment with the combat results proves that "the grass is always greener on the other side." Although no Allied units were outright eliminated, I did take major hits on two of my strongest units. I am most grateful for the SU combat result on Vielsalm because the defending unit will be sorely needed to shore up the river-line defense. The lack of a German mechanized exploitation threat in the far South made defense a little easier for me in that area. My inability to entice Tom to attack up the Monschau/Eupen Road, which would draw off a good part of his offensive strength, is proving a bit frustrating.

Tom is absolutely right. The presence of Skorzeny in Malmedy makes the defense in the immediate vicinity very tricky. I want very much to defend the hex 1607-1610 forest line but run the risk of getting two units trapped with a successful Skorzeny "sneak." There are two important bidges I would like to destroy this turn - those at Salmchateau and hex 1610. I feel comfortable with my defenses at Noville, Bastogne, and Martelange. The North is another story. A good part of 7th Armor seemed slightly out of position at the start of my turn. I would have liked to defend in hex 1813, but that would have been a prime target for a Skorzeny flanking maneuver. How Tom approaches the hidden fuel depot is highly problematic. If he gets bold and moves weak infantry next to it, he will trigger a perhaps early destruction attempt, allowing the Allies a second attempt to smoke it should the first attempt fail. I'm going to try an air interdiction so often successfully used by my good friend, John Grant. I will shut down the road net leading into Houffalize with judicious placement of my two air units. I know both Tom and I are anxiously awaiting the results of the 18AM Random Event. I hope to see something really atrocious.

--  Randy

LQ Rating:  4.0 LQ Rating:  3.17  (2 out of 3 bridges destroyed.)
Public Comments:

German Combat

Red = Outcome (LQ Rating)   Blue = German unit   Green = Allied Unit

1730:  Adj (30) vs 5 @5-1(-1) = 5 = 4 =D3 (5)

    28/110  to 2028

    5/13, 212/320, 352/915 to 1730; 26/39 to 1929

2024:  Adj + 766A + Air (48) vs 9/CCA + 174A (12) @4-1(-2) = 2 = 0 = 1D2 (2)

    9/CCA(r) to 2224

    2/304, 26/77, 212/316 to 2124; 212/423, 5/14 to 2024; 2/3 to 2025

2018:  Adj (50) vs 5 + 402A @4-1(-2) = 6 = 4 = D2 (6)

    99/394 to 2116

    Lehr 901 to 2119; Lehr Recon to 2018; Lehr 902 to 2017

1916:  Adj (13) vs 12 @1-1 = 5 = SU (5)

1612:  SS Panzer Scare = 1 = NO.  (Bravehearts.) (5.5)

1612:  Adj (50) vs 5 + 187,333A @4-1(-2) = 6 = 4 = D2 (6)

    99/395 to 1811

    12SS/25, 18/294, 3/9 to 1713

1507:  SS Panzer Scare = 5 = YES.  (Cluck-cluck!) (1.5)

1507:  Adj (44) + Air vs 12 + 406A @3-1(-2) = 1 = -1 = 1D1 (1)

    2/38 reduced; 2/38(r), 2/9 to 1606

    1SS/1 to 1506; 1SS/2, 326/753r, 12/48 to 1507

 

Allied Demolitions:

1. 1917 (1-3) = 2 = Boom! (2)

2. 1712 (1-4) = 4 = Boom! (2.5)

3. 1610 (1-3) = 4 = Fizzle. (5)